Skip to Content
Stream Live
More Streaming Options
Recently Played
View Full Playlist
SUPPORT
‹ Flicks with The Film Snob

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York

November 17, 2026
SUPPORT
Flicks with The Film Snob
Flicks with The Film Snob
The Only Living Pickpocket in New York
Loading
/


The Only Living Pickpocket in New York
is the second feature by writer-director Noah Segan. The ungainly title, it seems to me, is clearly inspired by the 1970 Simon & Garfunkle song “The Only Living Boy in New York,” which we don’t hear, and has nothing to do with this story outside of a nostalgic regard for New York City in the ‘70s. But no matter, it’s a treat because it stars one of our best actors in the lead, John Turturro.

He plays an aging pickpocket, Harry Lehman, who does a lot of his work in the subways, but (as we soon see) faces diminishing profits after the shift away from cash and toward credit cards, digital wallets, and increasingly well-protected smartphones. An early sequence shows him lifting a wallet from a young business type that does have some cash, which he takes, but then dumps the rest—phones, cards, etc.—in a mailbox. The pickpocketing scenes are nicely done, with shots of Turturro’s eyes moving furtively here and there as he notices purses, fanny packs, and tempting coat pockets on bystanders in crowds. He carries a lot of cash around, which makes him seem wealthy, but he lives in a run-down little apartment in the Bronx, taking care of his wife Rosie, who is catatonic and bedridden. It’s part of Segan’s romantic conception—a career thief who has a loyal, loving nature. His conversations with his wife, who never says anything, are a touching way to show what matters most deeply to his character.

One day, Harry sees a young man getting out of a beautifully restored 1969 Camaro, bumps into him and takes his wallet. Later he uses a penny trick to open the car and steal a gym bag. There’s a gun in the bag that he throws away. Then he visits his pawnbroker, played by Steve Buscemi, who looks over his stuff, but none of which is worth much. The wallet from the guy in the Camaro has a card with a USB extension. The pawnbroker tries to put the USB in his old computer, but they can’t read it. As it turns out, the trouble is that the Camaro guy is connected to a crime family, and he desperately needs to get the USB card back. And Dylan (that’s his name), notices that there was a ping on it at that pawnshop address. Soon the gangsters find out about Harry and come after him.

The plot, with its crime thriller elements, is handled smoothly, and the general improbabilities are not glaring enough to spoil our enjoyment. The big deal isn’t really the plot, it’s John Turturro’s clever portrayal of the veteran pickpocket, with his humor and his sadness (he has an estranged daughter) and a nimble resourcefulness.

Segan and his cinematographer, Sam Levy, have given the movie a burnished visual texture that we recognize from 1970s films set in New York. The musical score by Gary Lionelli nicely evokes the soul and funk soundtracks of that period without overdoing it. The always capable Giancarlo Esposito is on hand as a burned-out detective who’s known Harry for years. The Only Living Pickpocket in New York is a genre piece, not trying for deep meaning but managing the minor chords around themes of love and mortality with some skill. And all that, plus the great John Turturro.


TAGS
Bronx,   criminals,   disabled,   gangsters,   thievery,  

KXCI NEWSLETTER

Sign Up

SUPPORT
LOCAL RADIO

SUPPORT